5 Best Frozen Pizzas, Ranked By Taste Testers

From the humble cheese-only option to loaded supreme varieties, frozen pizza has evolved far beyond its cardboard-like origins. Innovations in flash-freezing techniques and premium ingredients have transformed these convenient pies, with some rivaling their fresh-made counterparts. After scouring dozens of supermarket options and consulting consumer reviews, we’ve identified the truly outstanding frozen pizzas worth stocking in your freezer. Which pies do you think are the best frozen pizzas? Let us know in the comments below.

The Most Delicious Frozen Pizzas, According to Foodies

1. DiGiorno

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by DiGiorno (@digiorno)

As the saying goes, “it’s not delivery, it’s DiGiorno!” Although not to be mistaken for a restaurant pie, this freezer favorite is guaranteed to satisfy in a pinch. While DiGiorno may not compete with a fresh-from-the-oven slice from a favorite pizza joint, Buzzfeed says it excels at what it does best. It’s fresh and fluffy, establishing its supremacy for a reason.

Restaurant Clicks hails DiGiorno as a veritable legend in the realm of frozen pizzas, making it an excellent choice for a quick pizza fix. While its flavors may be slightly milder than other options, the classic frozen pizza brand does not disappoint when enjoyed hot out of the oven.

But what makes DiGiorno stand out from the rest? Today says its pillowy crust that rises impressively is what takes the cake…or the pie, in this case. The cheese is also superior, resulting in “ooey-gooey mozzarella strands worthy of an Instagram Reel,” they write.

2. Newman’s Own

If your favorite pizza joint is famed for its delicious thin crust, Newman’s Own is what you’ll want to keep stocked in your freezer. Reviewers across the internet were wowed by the crunch and flavor of the brand’s popular thin crust pizzas. Delish recommends the brand for those desiring a thin and crispy pizza base. They also mention that the crispiness receives unanimous praise from tasters, who appreciated its substantial feel.

According to NY Times, Newman’s Own presents a slightly elevated version of the classic thin-crust style seen in brands like Tombstone and Red Baron. It tastes authentic, unlike other pies that you can tell are mass-produced by a machine.

While delicious, the best part of a Newman’s Own pizza is arguably not the taste but the good done with every purchase. Food Network applauds Newman’s Own for its quick and perfectly crisp crust. The pepperoni, made from real beef and pork without added nitrites, stands out with its generous portion on each slice. They mention that 100 percent of net profits are donated to charities and nonprofits.

3. Red Baron

A nostalgic favorite, Red Baron pizza might not be the first name that comes to mind when you think of a delicious frozen pizza. But numerous reviewers agree that this slice is more than worth the price of admission. Today says this brand is all the evidence you need that you don’t need expensive ingredients to make something delicious. They also suggest adding a dash of Tabasco for a little extra spice.

Delish agrees on the nostalgia factor that comes with grabbing a slice of Red Baron. They say it reminds them of the pizza of school cafeterias and birthday parties. They also commend the ratio of sauce to cheese.

But just because it resembles school lunch pizza doesn’t mean it isn’t high quality. In fact, Buzzfeed goes as far as to say it is the closest to New York-style as they come. Now, that’s impressive!

4. Amy’s

For a healthier choice, opt for an Amy’s pizza made with organic ingredients and no GMOs. But while it claims some health benefits, it doesn’t taste like a compromise. Their Four Cheese Pizza features a “combination of mozzarella, Parmesan, Fontina, and provolone,” according to Bon Appetit. “It also contains honey, most likely as a substitute for some sugar in the sauce (although it also contains some sugar, so who knows?), and red wine vinegar.” Delish finds this pie the most flavorful across all the brands they tested due to the impressive cheese quality. 

Restaurant Clicks does warn that it is on the smaller side compared to competitors in the freezer aisle. But it makes up for it in flavor! How? They say the crust is the perfect chewiness and the sauce is rich. Yum!

5. Tombstone

This pick is another that seems synonymous with pizza parties in elementary school. But believe it or not, this classic stands the test of time with great flavor at a great price. NY Times recommends this brand for the element of nostalgia that comes with it, paired with the inexpensive price point. “This pie screams sleepover pizza—delightful, if not wholesome—and does what it does well,” they add in their review.

While Tombstone offers the basic pepperoni and cheese pies, many reviewers say this is a pizza best enjoyed with plenty of toppings. For something loaded on the topping front, Today swears by their Supreme variety, which is loaded with pepperoni, peppers, olives, and sausage. What more could you ask for?

MSN says to try the Roadhouse Double Down Deluxe flavor. Why? They write: “This pizza is an obvious winner. The pie has a lot of flavors going on, but they all complement each other really well, plus the sauce is on point and the crust is just the right amount of crispy.”

Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. StudyFinds is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations. This article may contain affiliate links in which we receive a commission if you make a purchase.